Fuel Contracting: Play the Long Game
November 17, 2026
Written By Tim Danze
When the bombing of Iran began in February, I’ll admit I thought it would be over in very short order. It’s now eight months later, and the two sides seem locked in a stalemate.
The war with Iran and subsequent surge in fuel prices have reinforced a simple lesson: You need to have a plan and follow long-term seasonal market trends to manage fuel costs year after year.
A plan helps take emotion out of your decisions. That doesn’t make contracting easy, especially when prices are high and the outlook is uncertain, but it can help you stay on track rather than making decisions based on headlines or short-term market swings.
Remember the long-term trends
At the beginning of 2026, many major forecasters anticipated a significant glut of oil. The war involving Russia and Ukraine and the shutdown of the Strait of Hormuz in the Middle East turned that outlook on its head. We’ve seen how the year has unfolded, with retail fuel prices reaching new highs and national averages climbing. With conflicts continuing and no clear end in sight, many forecasters are now pushing the anticipated glut into 2027.
Will they be wrong again? We could certainly see an oversupply of oil next year. But no one knows for sure. That’s why I encourage you to stick with your contracting plan while adjusting the number of gallons you purchase to match your own outlook and risk tolerance.
No one can consistently predict what the market will do. However, I believe that participating in MFA Oil’s contracting program year after year can put you in a better position to succeed in the long run.
Will you save money every year? No. Will you sometimes contract gallons at prices that turn out to be higher than the market later offers? Absolutely. But over time, contracting can help make your overall fuel costs more consistent and reduce the impact of the extreme price volatility we’ve seen in energy markets.
Pay attention to seasonal opportunities
Historical trends offer useful guidance when planning fuel purchases. Over the past 10 years, NYMEX Heating Oil futures have peaked in the fall, averaging Oct. 13, around the end of harvest demand. Prices have typically moved toward seasonal lows between November and February, creating an opportunity to consider fixed-price contracts for the upcoming spring or fall.
Longer-term data reinforces this pattern. Since No. 2 heating oil futures began trading in 1978, prices have rallied from the second quarter to the fourth quarter in 39 of 43 years. Over the past 25 years, seasonal lows have generally occurred between November and February, with the weeks around Thanksgiving and Christmas often presenting a good time to consider contracting for the upcoming season.
These trends aren’t guarantees, and current market conditions still matter. They do, however, provide a starting point for making informed decisions.
Adjust your gallons to match your risk tolerance
Here’s where this coming seasonal window could get challenging. In my opinion, there’s a good chance the current conflicts will continue in some form when the market enters its traditional period for seasonal lows.
If prices remain elevated, many of us will be hesitant to lock in a price. We’ll hope the conflicts end and fuel prices come down, making it tempting to wait. But historical trends suggest that could be a mistake.
The answer isn’t necessarily to contract the same number of gallons every year, but to adjust the amount based on your comfort level and view of the market.
For example, if you normally contract 50% of your expected fuel usage but believe prices could fall further, you might choose to contract only 20%. If you’re more concerned that prices will rise, you might stick with your usual 50% or consider a different amount that fits your plan.
The point is to make a deliberate decision rather than sitting out the contracting season entirely because the market feels too uncertain.
Many people held back on contracting earlier this year because forecasters were predicting an oil glut. The situation changed dramatically as unrest in the Middle East sent prices higher. It’s easy to look back and see what we should have done. Making those decisions in real time is much harder.
That’s why I keep coming back to the same advice: Use the best information available, pay attention to seasonal trends and participate in some form of fuel contracting every year.
You don’t have to get every decision right to benefit from a long-term strategy. Over time, consistent participation can help smooth out the peaks and valleys in your fuel costs and make a volatile market a little easier to manage.




